|
|
Holland's theory of career interest and evaluation of individual
career
Introduction
People all wish to pursue the career that they are interested in. Some people
even pointed out that if people could pursue a job where they could find
interest, their life would be like in the heaven. However, problems also
occur at the same time. On one hand, people's interests are often not abroad,
but defined into some special fields and even some extreme aspects; on the
other hand, people often face thousands of occupation opportunities, thus
how to tell apart the most suitable and interesting job from others has
become the puzzles that disturb people. The first step suggested is to range
into groups of occupation from numerous job opportunities, and to find the
interesting job serves as the second step. Research on career classification
can be traced back to long time ago, but unanimous opinion has not been
achieved since then. Among all, related theory of John Holland, psychologist
and occupation guidance expert from the US, has been widely spread.
This dissertation will evaluate and analyze Holland's theory of career interests
in the following aspects. Part one is the brief introduction of Holland's
career interests theory. Second part is value analysis of career interest
theory. Third part is the enlightenment on individual's career design. Fourth
part is the implication of career interests in individual's career experience.
Final part is the conclusions.
Part One Brief introduction on Holland's career interests theory
Since 1959 Holland has started to carry out times of large-scale experimental
research on career selection. He wrote several books such as career decision
on that research topic. Of all his career theories, the most widely spread
one is the matching theory of personality and career. In that theory,
the classification model is equal to that of interest, so that the classification
of personality has often been introduced as the classification of interest.
He emphasized that the coordination of the same type of personality of
career can bring about the most desirable state. People all face many
choices in career, job, post and even specific project. Whether these
choices can be matched to the career is one of the most important factors
of success.(1)
Realistic tendency: people that have realistic tendency often have technological
and sports inclination. They often have comparatively strong coordination
ability of body techniques and mechanism, and show strong concern over
mechanism and bodies. They are steady, practical and willing to engage
into activities and technological work that have specific regulation.
Some of them are even crazy about manufacturing new objects by themselves.
They show not much ability on interpersonal skill and communication and
often have little interest in personnel administration and supervision.
Careers that match this type of people include: careers that require skilled
techniques, careers in the aspects of animal and plant administration,
in the administration of engineers, in manufacturing techniques, handicrafts,
and mechanism fittings and operations.
Investigative tendency: People who have investigative tendency show strong
interest in theoretical thinking or mathematical statistics. They often
show strong passion for the resolution of abstract problems. Also they
are inclined to resolve hard problems through thinking and analysis, although
the specific manipulation may not be fulfilled. Creative and challenging
works are to their taste, and routine tasks would not arouse their interests.
Leadership and interpersonal communication are not voluntary and the independency
inclination is obvious. Suitable jobs are analyst, designer and biologist
etc.
Art tendency: People who have art tendency show strong preference towards
creative, imaginary and self-appearance job. A similar characteristic
with investigative tendency people is that both of the two types show
obvious inclination of creation and dislikes of structural tasks and environments.
They have rare interest in routine job. Both of the two types of people
prefer to be independent. What distinguish the two types is that people
who have art tendency have obvious self-appearance inclination, attach
great importance to their instincts and feelings. Careers in the fields
are sculpt, handicrafts, dancing and drama.
Social tendency: People who have social tendency are willing to do jobs
involving interpersonal communication. They often have superior language
ability whereas inferior mathematical ability. Be good at communication
be glad to help others, be inclined to humanitarianism and having strong
responsibility are their characteristics. Such type of people is accustomed
to resolving problems through discussion with people or adjusting of interpersonal
relations. They show almost no interest in the job related to mechanism
and specific objects. Such type of people is fit for consulting, training
and persuasion job. Related career are in this fields of school and social
education, social welfare, medical and health care, marketing and direct
service.
Conventional tendency: People have conventional tendency are willing to
do orderly job with specific requirements. They are not adaptable to jobs
that have obscure regulation and large freedom. They don't prefer to make
decisions actively and are accustomed to obedience. Such type of people
is comparatively faithful, reliable and reserved. They would prefer to
keep certain distance with other people in the work. Working carefully
with perseverance, caring about social status and social evaluation are
the obvious characteristics of such type of people. General work in large-scale
organizations would be suitable for them. And the suitable careers are
bank employees, conservator of books, accounting, cashier, statistical
personnel, manipulator of computers and employees in the office.
Enterprising tendency: People who have enterprising tendency like formulating
new work plan and setting new organization, playing an active role in
activities. They like exerting impact, managing and leading others. Strong
confidence, predominance and risk-taking are the most distinguishing characteristics
of such type of people. They don't prefer to do specific work that requires
long time-span of concentration.
People usually tend to choose suitable career environment for their peculiar
personality and interests. For instance, people who have shown realistic
tendency could bring into full play his or her potential ability in matching
environment. However, in career selection, individuals do not have to
choose the matching career environment with his or her personality. One
reason is that individuals are often the integration of multi interests,
and people that have one single extraordinary tendency is in the minority,
so the evaluation of individual's interests categories are often combined
with the first three out of six types in the evaluation. And the interest
category is often ranged in the order of type, for instance, the type
could be RCA, AIS and so on. The other reasons is that the factors that
affect the career selection is various, and interest type is only part
of them. Social requirement on career and the possibilities of the acquisition
of the jobs should also be included as the factors. Hence, compromises
have to be done in career selection. And individuals have to learn to
adapt to work environment. If individuals could only find one career environment
that is on the contrary of his or her interest tendency, the individual
may probably find no pleasure from the job.
Part Two Value analysis of career interest theory
1. Positive evaluation of career interest theory
1.1 Value on the development of the theory
Career interest theory of John Holland reflects his long time practical
experience in career guidance in a concentrated way. In the organic combination
of formerly separated examination of individual difference in career interest
with the research on career and career environment, John Holland had established
the close relations between the two ways. Self-Directed Search, explored
by Holland is carried out on the basis of his former work Vocational Preference
Inventory. He seeks to find out two career abilities to correspond with
each career interest. The test method of finding out matching interest
is quite peculiar, and has shown big advantages in practice. The test
result explanation is more concise than before, and the combination of
interest test and ability test has played a promotion role in the application
of career guidance and consulting.(2)
Holland's interest theory has also advanced that interest is another method
that depicts personality and is a more general concept in career selection.
In his theory personality is regarded as the combination of interests,
value, needs, techniques, beliefs, attitudes and study personality. As
far as career selection is concerned, interest is the most important aspect
of personality in the matching process of people with career. Besides,
Holland has also advanced the theory of personality type of career interest.
He believes that individual's choice of career is under the dominance
of motivation, knowledge, interest and self-consciousness. The most important
factor people select career in certain fields is the impact of interest
and personality. This theory is regarded as one of the most influential
career development theory and career classification system.
1.2 Value on the recruitment of employees for enterprises
Holland had applied his theory of career-personality into DOT, and by
right of related content in the career analysis in DOT, the dictionary
of Holland Occupational Codes has been compiled in order to offer assistance
for people when searching suitable vocations according to their own career
interests type. Concisely speaking, before the advancement of Holland's
theory of career and personality, research on the differences among various
individuals in career interest (for instance the research of Francis)
and the gathering and arrangement on the career information (for instance
the DOT in the Labor Department of USA) has been conducted separately.
The advancement of Holland's theory has made the relations between career
interests and various careers more easily understood.
For recruiting enterprises, the carrying out of modern career interest
test has played an important role in the human resources management and
development. People can not only be tested on the whole, but the specific
aspect can also be tested. Hence, the test of career interest can not
only be applied in the advancement, examination and training of graduates
and employees in the transfer of posts and job selection.
1.3 Value on individual career
According to Holland's theory, people's career interests could affect
the satisfactory degree of careers. When the job is in accordance with
the interests, people's potential ability could be brought into full play,
and thus achievement could be made. With the help of career interests
test, the hard problems can be resolved easily in search of interesting
job. For students and people with little employment experience in particular,
Holland's career interest test could help them make vocational design
and bring into full play their ability in their job more easily.
In specific, career interest test tools could help individual make career
design and vocation development plan. This tool can help employees and
people looking for job reposition, realize and develop their ability on
the whole.
2. Query on the validity of career interest theory
Career test should include both subjective and objective tests. In traditional
recruitments, the most often-used subjective test tools include interview,
examination on certificate and resume evaluation. Honestly speaking, the
above methods may probably help the acquisition of some useful information,
however, obvious weaknesses also exist: 1. The acquisition of information
is superior, and the deep content could not be easily acquired; 2. The
evaluation of current status is the major part, and the potential ability
could not be easily evaluated; 3. Qualitative description takes the major
part without sufficient quantitative analysis tool; 4. Dependence on subjective
experience and lack of objective evaluation standards; In a word, non-standard
and subjectivity could greatly reduce the effectiveness of recruitment.
With the development of subjects of psychology, statistics, and management,
standard and objective employees test methods have arisen in the place
of former commonly used recruitment method and have been more and more
widely used in reality.
Part Three Enlightenment on individual's career design
1. Implication of interest on individual's career design
Firstly, interest is one of the most important bases for career selection.
IT serves as a strong spiritual power. Interests can make people concentrate
on the career knowledge he or she likes and enlightened to conduct creative
job. When people' interests grow on certain vocation, they would put all
their energy and activity into the job. Consciousness and attention to
the knowledge, dynamics of the vocation would arise, as well as affluent
imagination, enhanced spirit of overcoming difficulties and memory.
Secondly, interest can help improve work efficiency and promote the exertion
of abilities. Once people's interest of work is inspired, dull work will
grow colorful and interesting. Interests have made work no longer burdens
but enjoyment. People once conducted a research and found that if people
are engaged in interesting jobs, 80-90% of total abilities could be bring
about, and never feel tired even long time of work. And if people could
not find interest from the job, only 20-30% of the abilities could be
bring about.
Thirdly, interests are important factors that could ensure the stability
and success of career. Interests serve as one of the major sources of
the career motivation. Other things being equal, the engagement of interesting
job could not only bring satisfaction but also affection toward job, which
would lead to the stability of the job. In addition, interests in many
fields could make people easily cope with the ever-changing environment.
2. Career design of individuals according to career interest
Career design is people's planning of career development in the future,
the objective of which is to help individuals bring into full play all
the potentials of the individual and make the career more happily. The
content of career design includes career objectives, career development
path, upcoming preparations; development plan involving career choosing
and adjustment; adjustment and preparation in terms of self-consciousness,
knowledge, ability, technological training, behavior and attitude, value
opinion. Reasonable career design should be conducted in two aspects of
subjectivity and objectivity. In subjective aspect, value opinion, attitude,
motivation, ability and development direction. Social and organizational
environment should be considered as objective aspect.
From the above analysis we could deduce that the first step of career
design is self-consciousness, which means individual characteristics analysis.
Only after correct consciousness of people themselves could correct analysis
and selection of people's future career development be conducted and suitable
career development path be determined. Usually, individual's characteristics
analysis includes several aspects in individual's interests, ability,
personality and behavior style. Analysis methods on people's characteristics
include test method and self-introspect method. Test method uses psychology,
management and some other subjects and technologies comprehensively to
measure and evaluate people's ability, inclination, characteristics, and
behaviors systematically and objectively. Self-introspect method mainly
recognizes individual's characteristics through the observation of themselves
and other people's reaction toward themselves. Test method is comparatively
systematic and objective however cannot exist without the assistance of
specific tool. Self-introspect method is easy to be conducted, but would
usually be affected by some prejudice and self-consciousness ability.
Final test results of the two methods reflect people's career interests
that would determine their career selection.
Part Four Implication of career interests in individual's career experience
1. Test of career interests
Career interest is reflected as peculiar psychological characteristics
by the combination of the variety, complexity of careers and the variety
of working people. Career interests differ among themselves, and the difference
is quite obvious. On one hand, modern social career has been greatly segmented,
and the requirement and regulations of social activities has become more
and more complicated, so that the differences among various vocations
have become more and more obvious, and the appealing and requirements
of individuals has varied greatly between one and another. On the other
hand, the difference of physical, psychological, educational, social and
economic status and background of individuals has lead to the differences
of career type choices.
It is quite necessary to conduct career interests tests for people when
they are choosing their careers. It can help people determine his or her
subjective inclination so that the most suitable environment is likely
to be offered and the individual could be likely to put all his or her
energy into the new environment and job. Career test also serves as an
important role in the choosing and allocation of the management Selection
on the basis of ability appraisal could help achieve the biggest earnings
and the most successful activities (vocation).
2. Definition of career interests
Career interests are shown as peculiar personality inclination when people
are exploring certain vocation or are engaged in certain career activities.
Such interests render people give priority to certain jobs when in search
of jobs and make people yearn for that vocation. Roles of career interest
in career activities are that it would exert an impact on career orientation
and career selection, help promote and exploring of wisdom, mine potential
ability and improvement of work efficiency.(3)
Social responsibility, content, nature and style of work, service measures
of each career is quite different, which has decided that each career
has its peculiar requirements on the interests of the working people.
The difference of forming process and the factors exerting impacts of
each people has also help the formation of complex and various career
interests. For each people, search of career to his or her taste should
be conducted according to the result of career interests test and the
classification and selection of various careers and career interests.
First of all, the satisfaction of current knowledge and experiences accumulation
is not enough. The outstanding appearance of lacking interests in work
is the satisfaction of current knowledge and experiences accumulation,
and the result is always the slow development and growth of the individual.
Lack of enterprising spirit in work and satisfaction of general manipulation
and common sense is no good for the cultivation of work interests. And
the writer's suggestion is that to cultivate career interests, the deep
understanding of the principles of the job and no satisfaction of general
manipulation is very important.
Second step is to mine the deep reasons instead of the superior appearance.
Problems, especially some extraordinary problems are always pregnant with
some new leap. Take the fall of apples on the ground for an example. Nobody
except for Newton couldn't help search of the deep reasons of the phenomenon.
And the result for that is that Newton find out the truth, thus the universal
gravitation has been found out. More search of the deep reasons and thinking
of the problems is very helpful for the cultivation of career interests.
Third step is to go ahead facing all the difficulties. Interests cultivation
is sometimes not a natural process, which means that not all the inborn
interests could form career interests finally. Actually, in the cultivation
of interests, many difficulties exist on the path. If people cannot face
straight all the problems, and give up in the face of the difficulties,
the cultivation of interests would just stop.
Final step is to cultivate interests in the work. In the actual working
process, there are not only hard bitter, but also pleasures when the difficulties
got resolved perfectly. Not only pleasure of success but also the summaries
of lessons of failure are also helpful for the formation of interests.
So the writer believes that more working pleasures should be experienced
in practice, and the cultivation of career interests should be gradually
promoted, that is step by step.
Ding zhaozhong, who used to win the Nobel Prize of physics, once said,
interests are more important than talent. Practice has also proved that
among all the subjective factors that affect the planning and development
of individual career experience. Interests are just like invisible hands
and play the biggest role. Each people should focus on career interests
in the career experiences planning.
Career inclination is at the same time career interest. It serves as the
basis of the whole career. What cannot be ensured is the loyalty of people
to enterprises, but what can be realized is that people tend to be loyalty
to the job to his or her taste. If people could choose a career according
to his or her interests, his or her go-aheadism spirit will be fully inspired.
Even tiresome and difficulties could not prevent the light pleasure and
vigorous. Even if temporary difficulty cannot be easily overcome, people
will not easily give up. Instead, he will try everything he can to overcome
the difficulties and even forget sleep and food, totally absorbed in it.
Edison is a good example. He almost spend more than ten hours in the laboratory,
eating and sleeping there without any bitter feeling.(4)
Part Five Conclusions
The reason why Holland's career interests theory has been widely recognized
and applied cannot be separated from the application value. It is a good
tool for the recruitment of enterprises and employees appraisal. For people
applying for jobs, the recognition of the career interests and the selection
of interesting jobs play important roles and sometimes even irreplaceable
place.
As researcher on human resource management, pure understanding of Holland's
career interests theory is far from enough. What is important is how to
apply the theory into actual work practice. In particular, for people
how to cultivate individual's interests by right of interest theory or
to bring into full play individual's ability still needs further research.
In addition, Holland's career interests theory is not perfect, and many
weaknesses still exist. This theory still needs supplement and perfection,
and this task is an important task for human resource managers.
Bibliography:
(1) Li Qiu, Career Psychology, Page 345, Jiangxi High School Press, 2001
(2) Zhangyan, Career Psychology, Page 45, 1987
(3) Bai Ligang, Measure and Research of Career Interests, Page 87, Psychological
research Center of China's Academy of Science,1995
(4) Lu Xu, Change Your Lifestyle, Page 119, Economic Science Press, 2003
|